The high jinx of the 'High-Performance Review'
Fans play on the pitch during the lunch interval of Surrey v Essex in 2022. The real ‘inspiring of generations’
One of the main issues I have about the ECB’s High-Performance Review is... well... it is all about High Performance.
Don’t get me wrong, we all want top-quality, truly competitive, ever-improving sport. This is the entertainment for the fan, the endeavour for the athlete and underpins the business model for the organisation. It also supports the ideals of physical play, hence the Olympic motto - "faster, higher, stronger".
However, sport is much more than merely high-performance. It is about meaning and identity, something that is conferred through the generations by storytelling.
To put it another way - I like cricket because my Dad did. I am an Essex fan because my Dad was. And, as regular readers will know, I have tried my darnedest to pass on these passions to my kids.
This is what ‘inspiring generations’ really means.
Having worked in elite sports organisations, it is clear they believe, as one of my former CEOs put it, "a winning team solves everything". And from their perspective, it ticks most of the major boxes - more money through media, commercial and tickets, greater prestige, greater glory and a massive ego boost.
But ‘everything’ is an all-encompassing, immovable word while ‘winning’ is always temporary. Manchester City have been more successful than Manchester United for the past decade but the latter remain the bigger club. City still get ridiculed over the number of empty seats at the Etihad Stadium and the financial source of their success. Essex have won more trophies than any other county since 1979 but have they stolen any fans from their rivals because of it? Not one, I suspect.
Look at this major survey from the European (Football) Club's Association (4,000 respondents spread across Europe, N America and China). It tells us that family connection is the most important reason for interest in football across all demographics bar one, where content and story take the top spot. Team success is only No 3 or No 4.
My point is not about using the majority of your focus and resources to try and be successful on the pitch. It is about using almost all your focus and resources to the detriment of other key drivers. I have seen stupid money gambled on that flakey player who "might add a bit" and featherbedding their foibles when redirecting just a fraction would have created a best-in-class marketing and content team.
This survey would suggest a High-Performance Review is needed but only after one covering content/story and, most importantly of all, the How-To-Get-Your-Kids-To-Support-The-Same-Team-As-You report.
In this graph, “favourite club was successful’ was the fifth most important reason for a fan following football in Europe. In the US and China, it was not in the top five
Of course, success is relevant to that last venture. The late primary school years are considered key in the consolidation of lifelong fandom and my personal passion was surely based partly on the fact that I was nine when Essex won their first trophy in 1979. I distinctly remember listening on the radio when we won the Championship again a couple of years later.
But all this was mediated through my Dad. He told me what it all meant and seeing his excitement rubbed off.
The ECA survey adds that, in relative terms, younger fans are less influenced by family, less devoted to clubs but more likely to be lured by social media, content and the fitness gained by participation.
Selling anything to the young is a very different beast these days, especially sport. For a start there are strict laws about marketing to pre-teens and, though it is almost entirely ignored, most social media platforms require users to be at least 13.
But, above all that, sporting stories are different now. Footballers are known as much through their ratings on the online game FIFA than anything they do on the pitch and YouTuber creators-turned-boxers are selling more pay-per-views buys for their fights than world champions. We all know the tournament-that-shall-not-be-named is so similar to T20 as makes no difference but the sizzle sold around it is light years beyond the way the ECB has ever marketed county cricket.
The experience (72%) is what 16-24 year-old fans crave most from a football match but identity is close behind on 62%
The irony of all this is that the High-Performance Review was prompted by our failure in the Ashes, a regular occurrence that, yet again, does not make me less interested the next time it comes around as memories of sporadic successes still provide hope. Yet Test cricket seems well down the agenda for the ECB, moving next year's Ashes to accommodate you-know-what would seem definitive.
Over the past couple of cricketing decades, as we have lurched from crisis to crisis, nadir to nadir, review to review, we have never got a clear sense of the priorities in the game from our governing body. Surely that should determine where you put your time, money and focus.
And now, having lost control to franchise tournaments based on their very own invention, they are desperately trying to regain a foothold with a big review, with a big name running it.
The review to end all reviews.
This is it.
Final.
No more.
Nope.
All done.
…errr, until the next one.
If ‘character is destiny’ it will be the same brand of bollocks we have seen before and, because we have no agreement or understanding on the priorities, the execution will be fudged due to competing pressures.
The ECA report shows clearly, what is apparent to everyone, high performance is very important but NOT all-important.
It is folly for the ECB to think otherwise.
-
October 2023
- Oct 10, 2023 Cricket in the Olympics: The REAL reason for a long-awaited second innings Oct 10, 2023
-
February 2023
- Feb 6, 2023 The REAL value is sport is immeasurable Feb 6, 2023
-
September 2022
- Sep 16, 2022 The high jinx of the 'High-Performance Review' Sep 16, 2022
-
August 2022
- Aug 6, 2022 How county cricket can regenerate like Dr Who Aug 6, 2022
-
November 2021
- Nov 30, 2021 The art of the exit interview Nov 30, 2021
-
October 2021
- Oct 14, 2021 Never change, non-league football Oct 14, 2021
-
January 2021
- Jan 15, 2021 Content Lessons: Frank Sidebottom/Chris Sievey Jan 15, 2021
-
December 2020
- Dec 4, 2020 Content Lessons: Mark Kermode and Simon Mayo's Film Reviews Dec 4, 2020
-
November 2020
- Nov 26, 2020 Content Lessons: Carlito's Way pool hall scene Nov 26, 2020
-
August 2020
- Aug 25, 2020 The names have been changed to attracted the interested Aug 25, 2020
-
July 2020
- Jul 7, 2020 The fans who buy players for their football team Jul 7, 2020
-
May 2020
- May 27, 2020 Three lessons from Jesse Cole May 27, 2020
-
February 2020
- Feb 3, 2020 Ideas, ownership and the art of ‘getting it done’ Feb 3, 2020
-
January 2020
- Jan 24, 2020 Highlighting the humanity of punching people Jan 24, 2020
- Jan 11, 2020 2020: The digisport 'list of lists' Jan 11, 2020
-
November 2019
- Nov 18, 2019 Is this the best sports video ever? Nov 18, 2019
-
September 2019
- Sep 13, 2019 While we wait for VAR to come good, let's decide what we REALLY want from our football Sep 13, 2019
- Sep 6, 2019 KSIvPaul2: Revenge, redemption and revealing a new boxing market Sep 6, 2019
-
August 2019
- Aug 15, 2019 My social media secret Aug 15, 2019
-
June 2019
- Jun 3, 2019 I'm a loser baby, but why do you 'kill' me? Jun 3, 2019
-
May 2019
- May 6, 2019 Someone told sports content's biggest lie... again May 6, 2019
-
March 2019
- Mar 22, 2019 Sounds like a mistake. Why the BBC's new app is all wrong Mar 22, 2019
-
January 2019
- Jan 30, 2019 A sporting paradise lost? My favourite interview defined his success his own way Jan 30, 2019
- Jan 14, 2019 Sunderland Till I Die: Wear and Tears as a struggling club goes OTT Jan 14, 2019
-
December 2018
- Dec 30, 2018 Sport’s Content Strategy’s 'List of Lists' - looking back on 2018 and ahead to 2019 Dec 30, 2018
-
November 2018
- Nov 2, 2018 What's the story, sporting glory? Nov 2, 2018
-
October 2018
- Oct 20, 2018 What this ticket tells us about the modern matchday experience Oct 20, 2018
-
August 2018
- Aug 31, 2018 The Inbetweeners: Why Man City's Amazon series did not live up to its title Aug 31, 2018
-
July 2018
- Jul 24, 2018 Global Benchmark: Real beat Barca, Schalke take China, Mexico rise and Man United's YouTube growth Jul 24, 2018
- Jul 23, 2018 Introducing Sports Content Strategy Jul 23, 2018
-
June 2018
- Jun 16, 2018 Can matchday be reprogrammed? Jun 16, 2018
- Jun 5, 2018 Indonesian football Year 2: bigger crowds, island-hopping and digital acceleration Jun 5, 2018
-
May 2018
- May 19, 2018 Content lessons for the team that did not win a League game all season... but did not sack their manager May 19, 2018
- May 13, 2018 Thanks for your quality: 10 examples of the exceptional Arsene Wenger May 13, 2018
- May 3, 2018 How Zaphod Beeblebrox, the Monkees, U2's albums and my car insurance help explain the problems faced by young content creators May 3, 2018
-
March 2018
- Mar 24, 2018 Overachievers: The St Pauli story Mar 24, 2018
- Mar 21, 2018 Notes on SXSW18: Luke Skywalker, the CIA and the trendy podcast thing Mar 21, 2018
- Mar 11, 2018 Overachievers: Boxing must counter-punch UFC on social media, right now! Mar 11, 2018
-
February 2018
- Feb 25, 2018 Why I love... Lukas Podolski Feb 25, 2018
-
January 2018
- Jan 23, 2018 The OTT platform who stole Christmas TV and Black Mirror > Doctor Who Jan 23, 2018
- Jan 8, 2018 FC Global: Notes on the 179 football clubs with over 1m social media followers Jan 8, 2018
- Jan 1, 2018 What is your off-the-wall sports social media prediction for 2018? Jan 1, 2018
-
December 2017
- Dec 31, 2017 My favourite social post by a football club in 2017 is.... Dec 31, 2017
-
November 2017
- Nov 23, 2017 Football documentaries: fly-on-the-wall or fly in the ointment? Nov 23, 2017
- Nov 7, 2017 If content were really king then creators would be treated like royalty Nov 7, 2017
-
October 2017
- Oct 5, 2017 The accidental experiment that proves media consumption is changing... and BT are terrible Oct 5, 2017
-
September 2017
- Sep 22, 2017 How Ultimate Team cards helped the FIFA video game do a number on all-comers Sep 22, 2017
- Sep 18, 2017 The Overachievers: Yeovil Town - how signing a player in real life (and then on FIFA17) created the 'reveal' of the summer Sep 18, 2017
-
August 2017
- Aug 30, 2017 So I 'Started With Why'... Aug 30, 2017
- Aug 26, 2017 Notoriety v Money - The C(l)ash of Styles in the Fight before the Fight Aug 26, 2017
- Aug 19, 2017 How one email lost a short-term customer but gained long-term trust Aug 19, 2017
- Aug 7, 2017 Europe's most followed players bask in the shadow of Barcelona and Real Madrid Aug 7, 2017
-
July 2017
- Jul 23, 2017 Instagram, Leagues, SINA WEIBO and fairytales - ALL UP IN 2016/17 Jul 23, 2017
- Jul 15, 2017 EPL ✔︎, Europe ✔︎, USA ✔︎ - Now for 'Football Indonesia' Jul 15, 2017
-
June 2017
- Jun 30, 2017 How McGregor is running rings around Mayweather on social media Jun 30, 2017
- Jun 19, 2017 Content lessons from a 10 year-old boy Jun 19, 2017
-
May 2017
- May 31, 2017 27,000 in the stadium, 14m watching online - Lessons from Sidemen vs the YouTube AllStars May 31, 2017
- May 23, 2017 XFL v NFL, Packer v Cricket, Me v Mr Gowlett - taking on the establishment May 23, 2017
- May 8, 2017 WTF! Our CRM system is going through a VBC (very big change) May 8, 2017
-
April 2017
- Apr 29, 2017 Joshua v Klitschko - the social media fight Apr 29, 2017
- Apr 5, 2017 What the IPL! Why is digital sport ignoring Indian T20 cricket? Apr 5, 2017
-
March 2017
- Mar 18, 2017 Faster, higher, stronger imagery - @Olympics on Instagram Mar 18, 2017
- Mar 4, 2017 Best of Luck #Rapids96, remember to Keep Fighting Mar 4, 2017
- Mar 3, 2017 Storytelling, soccer and speaking at SXSW - part 2 Mar 3, 2017
-
February 2017
- Feb 22, 2017 Why I love... Wolves' programme covers Feb 22, 2017
- Feb 7, 2017 Notes on how to reveal signings in the January transfer window - Euro edition Feb 7, 2017
- Feb 3, 2017 Why I love... Andrea Pirlo's fireball Feb 3, 2017
-
January 2017
- Jan 31, 2017 The philosophical way to make digital sports content (or all creativity is theft) Jan 31, 2017
- Jan 18, 2017 SBI talk - the links Jan 18, 2017
- Jan 11, 2017 Cut Out, Cut Back or Reshape - Why your digital sport diet has to start TOO! Jan 11, 2017
- Jan 2, 2017 Digital Sport and SportsBiz Predictions 2017 — List of Lists Jan 2, 2017
-
December 2016
- Dec 31, 2016 Sportsbiz and Digisport - list of lists for 2016 Dec 31, 2016
-
November 2016
- Nov 26, 2016 Where is the sporting version of the Serial podcast? Nov 26, 2016
- Nov 20, 2016 How UFC is beating boxing to the punch Nov 20, 2016
-
October 2016
- Oct 26, 2016 Is football (⚽️&🏈) under threat? Oct 26, 2016
- Oct 20, 2016 Historic, global and unique - why every modern football club should envy Corinthian Casuals FC Oct 20, 2016
- Oct 8, 2016 Trainspotting, unboxing videos and the lust for digital innovation in sport Oct 8, 2016
-
September 2016
- Sep 29, 2016 Will Twitter and NFL both win Thursday Night Football games? Sep 29, 2016
- Sep 21, 2016 It’s how you play the game – digital, social and sports recruitment Sep 21, 2016
-
August 2016
- Aug 30, 2016 “The Rio Olympics was a digital sport failure.” Discuss Aug 30, 2016
- Aug 27, 2016 Vote for my SXSW talk Aug 27, 2016
- Aug 8, 2016 Analysing the SkyBet Championship 2016/17 – who’ll win the digital title? Aug 8, 2016
-
July 2016
- Jul 27, 2016 5 Digital Sport trends for SEAT Vegas Jul 27, 2016
- Jul 25, 2016 How Italy and Instagram won Euro2016 Jul 25, 2016
- Jul 12, 2016 Six key digisport trends for the 2016 Olympics in Rio Jul 12, 2016
-
June 2016
- Jun 26, 2016 Best Digisport Moments from Euro2016 - Official Teams: Group Stages Jun 26, 2016
- Jun 16, 2016 The best digisport content from Euro2016 so far (non-official) Jun 16, 2016
- Jun 11, 2016 Best Digisport Moments From Euro 2016 - Pre-Tournament Jun 11, 2016
- Jun 6, 2016 Muhammad Ali - a Social Media genius before it even existed Jun 6, 2016
-
May 2016
- May 10, 2016 Oil slick or oil tanker - who has the most engaging formula in motor sport? May 10, 2016
-
April 2016
- Apr 26, 2016 The authentic > the aesthetic Apr 26, 2016
- Apr 13, 2016 When Life Gives You Lemons - The Digital Humanity Of James Taylor And Fabrice Muamba Apr 13, 2016
-
March 2016
- Mar 26, 2016 Ronda Rousey, Vernon Davis, Sanya Richards-Ross And The Quest For Authenticity - Lessons From SXSports Mar 26, 2016
- Mar 2, 2016 Five #DigiSport 'Takeaways' from Sports Fan Engagement 2016 Mar 2, 2016
-
February 2016
- Feb 25, 2016 Ronaldo - the first 200m footballer Feb 25, 2016
- Feb 24, 2016 How the Panthers won The Superbowl (on Twitter) Feb 24, 2016